First up we have the new Lotus Elise. This thing is purpose built, and even more uncomfortable to ride in than my Subi (which is saying something).
Pros: Its a riot to drive. Built for the sole purpose of being nimble, quick and fairly affordable (its 2nd on the "price" list of these three cars. Also.. look at it.
Cons: I have trouble getting in and out of it. Yes. *I* have trouble. Which is almost a Pro, just for out obscene it is.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7b6e1/7b6e18bc1fc2f1c77ca0f69945de6ba8c380e39d" alt=""
Car #2 - the most expensive (~70 grand). This is the new Nissan Skyline (GT-R) - which is like my Subaru.. if it mated with a Ferrari. This thing is AWD, but has 100 HP on my car - and enough bells and whistles (the middle console was developed by the same people that coded one of my favorite video games - Gran Turismo) to make even the most info / toy happy person satisfied.
Pros: AWD, Huge huge performace; might actually be a better ride than the Subi (Okay, it would be).
Cons: Its 70+ grand. Ouchy. For a Nissan. Ouchy ouchy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5ac47/5ac47b9bd5c734bda37a8bff6b6008b012e93f34" alt=""
Ahh, the Volt. My little voice of reason (hahhahah.. reason in THIS list?). The promise of a gas free commute, and probably the nicest ride of the bunch (specially at only ~30 grand).
Pros: Gas Economy. Saving the planet (ha).
Cons: Its built by GM, so my repair bill is going to suck. That and I'll need a premium AAA account.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0750b/0750bf4cb65677c971540e1b2163288328d69d72" alt=""
Side Note: Seattle Seahawk's kicker Josh Brown is awesome